ABORTION, MATERNAL MORTALITY

(See also “Abortion,” “Abortion, Legal/Illegal,” “Abortion, Safe/Unsafe,”
“Abortion, Safe Motherhood,” “Sexual and Reproductive Health”)

 

 

Return to Table of Contents

 

Overview

 

Relentlessly, abortion is being presented as the solution to maternal mortality. Abortion advocates often point to maternal mortality rates (MMR) and illegal abortion rates that have been exaggerated or miscalculated and use these rates to claim that legalizing abortion will decrease maternal deaths. They argue that legalizing abortion makes it “safe,” as mothers can openly seek out competent doctors to perform legal abortions. For example, the World Health Organization claims, “To avoid maternal deaths … All women, including adolescents, need access to contraception, [and] safe abortion services to the full extent of the law.(World Health Organization. (2015). Maternal Mortality Fact sheet N°348.  https://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs348/en/)

 

However, the abortion procedure, regardless of the conditions under which it is performed, or whether it is legal or illegal, always carries health risks (see below), some even life threatening. The true solution to high maternal mortality rates is not abortion, but better health care, as the highest rates of maternal deaths, whether pregnancy-related or abortion-related, occur in developing countries with inadequate health care.

 

Here are some important facts regarding maternal mortality and abortion:

 

  • There are risks to pregnant women whether pregnancy is ended by abortion or live birth. The key to lowering maternal mortality rates (MMR) is to improve and increase access to health care services, not to legalize abortion.

 

  • Illegal abortion rates are often inflated or minimized to pressure countries into legalizing abortion.For example, in Mexico, abortion advocates claimed an annual illegal abortion rate close to 200,000[2] and pushed for legalized abortion as the answer. Yet, less than five years after legalizing abortion, total legal abortions were reported to be less than 20,000. Venezuela claimed an illegal abortion rate of more than 33,000 and after abortion was legalized, the reported number of legal abortions was reported to be closer 6,000. Studies showed, however, that these dramatic drops in actual abortions were not due to lower abortion, but rather to inaccurate reporting of illegal abortions in the needs analysis. Also, for years, abortion advocates at the UN claimed a global maternal mortality rate of over 500,000 annually, then later new data were published showing the rate was much closer to 300,000. (Koch, E., Aracena, P., Gatica, S.  Bravo, M., Huerta-Zepeda, A., & Calhoun, B. C. (2012). Fundamental discrepancies in abortion estimates and abortion-related mortality: A reevaluation of recent studies in Mexico with special reference to the International Classification of Diseases. International Journal of Women’s Health, 4, 613-623.)

   

 

Talking Points

 

1.     Abortion, even when performed in the safest or legal conditions, still carries serious health risks. In one study, 17 percent of women undergoing “safe” (i.e., legal) abortion procedures in the United States experienced physical complications (such as abdominal bleeding or pelvic infection) after the abortion.[1] The percentage is likely higher when long-term physical effects are considered, not to mention psychological effects. Some of the short- and long-term adverse effects of abortion, legal or illegal, include:[2]

 

    • Accidental tearing of uterine artery, tearing of the cervix, or scarring of the uterine wall
    • Heavy bleeding, requiring blood transfusions
    • Abdominal cramping, nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, and infection
    • Allergic reaction to drugs or anesthesia, sometimes causing convulsions, or worse
    • Heart attack, embolisms (caused by blood clots or other foreign matter in blood vessels)
    • Perforation of the uterus and damage to other internal organs
    • Miscarriage of future pregnancies, infertility or sterility
    • Increased risk of subsequent tubal pregnancies
    • Death (it is estimated that 20 percent of maternal deaths are due to abortion)
    • Guilt, anger, anxiety, depression, suicidal thoughts
    • Anniversary grief, flashbacks of abortion, memory repression
    • Sexual dysfunction, relationship problems
    • Eating disorders, sleep disorders
    • Alcohol and drug abuse

     

2.     Legalizing abortion does not lower maternal mortality rates because abortion has nothing to do with saving women’s lives. In some cases, it may be necessary to deliver a baby early to save the life of a mother and, as a result of the premature birth, the baby may not survive; however, it is never necessary to deliberately kill a baby to save the life of a mother.

  1.  

3.     Most maternal deaths are not caused by abortion whether legal or illegal, they are caused by a lack of basic health care. This text should focus on language providing better access to competent health care and avoid a controversial abortion debate.[3]

  1. A 2013 meta-analysis of multiple studies showed main causes of maternal deaths in some countries include:[4]

 

  1. Lack of access to clean water (Mexico, South Africa)Poor sanitation (Mexico, South Africa)Female illiteracy (Mexico, South Africa)Intimate partner violence (Mexico)HIV/AIDS (A large percentage of deceased women who were counted as maternal deaths in South Africa were found to be infected with HIV.)Obesity (South Africa, Britain, and one in three women of reproductive age in the United States)Heart disease (United States, Britain)Substandard care (South Africa)

    Lack of transportation, or living in remote areas (South Africa)

     

    We should be focusing on solutions to these major causes of maternal mortality.

     

4.     Focusing on the promotion of abortion could potentially raise maternal mortality rates by taking vital funding, focus and time away from providing basic health care services to pregnant women.

 

5.     If legalizing abortion reduces maternal mortality rates, it would follow that countries with permissive abortion laws would have low maternal mortality rates, and countries with more restrictive laws would have the highest maternal mortality rates. However, using data from the World Bank, consider the following:

 

    • A number of countries with highly restrictive abortion laws—such as Poland, Kuwait, United Arab Emirates, Cyprus, Libya, Malta, and Chile—had very low maternal mortality rates in 2015.[5] (See data below.)
    • Sierra Leone reports numbers that show they reduced their maternal mortality rate (MMR) by 48.3 percent between 1990 and 2015 without access to legal abortion. Very few countries have lowered MMRs to such a degree.
    • Without legal abortion, Chile also reduced their maternal mortality rate by 64.1 percent between 1990 and 2015. Chile did this, not with abortions, but by implementing maternal and perinatal health programs and abortion prevention.
    • The mortality rate due to abortion in Chile has continuously decreased over the past 50 years.
    • Maternal death in Chile as a result of induced abortion has become exceptionally rare (a risk of 1 in 4 million pregnant women of fertile age).[6]
    • The British Medical Journal published a study of 32 states in Mexico that found:
      • States in Mexico with abortion laws that restrict abortion reported 23 percent lower overall maternal mortality and up to 47 percent lower mortality from complications of abortion.
      • Less permissive abortion laws were not associated with increased maternal and abortion-related deaths in official maternal mortality data from 32 states of Mexico between 2002 and 2011.
      • Maternal healthcare, fertility, access to clean water, sanitation, female literacy and intimate-partner violence were the factors affecting 51 percent to 88 percent of differences in maternal mortality in the 32 Mexican states.[7]
    • The legalization of abortion in 1973 in the United States had no apparent impact on the already-declining number of abortion-related deaths.[8]

     

    A comparison of MMRs with abortion laws in Latin American and Caribbean countries shows there is no consistent correlation between the two. For example, as shown below, Chile, with some of the most restrictive abortion laws, has a comparatively low maternal mortality rate (22) while Guyana, with very permissive laws, has a very high maternal mortality rate (229). But there are also high maternal mortality rates in countries with more restrictive laws (Suriname, 155, and Haiti, 359) and low rates in some countries with little restrictions (Puerto Rico, 14, and Uruguay, 15). These figures show conclusively that legalizing abortion is not the answer to maternal mortality.

     

  1. Abortion Laws and Maternal Mortality Rates in Latin America and the Caribbean (The number in parentheses following each country is an estimate of maternal mortality ratio, MMR, maternal deaths per 100,000 live births.) Abortion is prohibited: Chile (MMR 22), El Salvador (MMR 54), Dominican Republic (MMR 92), Honduras (MMR 129), Jamaica (MMR 89), Nicaragua (MMR 150), Suriname (MMR 155), Haiti (MMR 359)Permitted for saving life of mother, rape, fetal impairment (at state level): Mexico (MMR 38), Brazil (MMR 44), Guatemala (MMR 88), Panama (MMR 94), Venezuela (MMR 95), Paraguay (MMR 132), Antigua and Barbuda (no stats), Dominica (no stats)Permitted for physical health and saving life of mother: Costa Rica (MMR 25), Grenada (MMR 27), Argentina (MMR 52), Ecuador (MMR 64), Peru (MMR 68), Bahamas (MMR 80), Bolivia (MMR 206)Permitted for mental health & all above reasons: St Lucia (MMR 48), Trinidad and Tobago (MMR 63), Colombia (MMR 64), St. Kitts and Nevis (no stats)

     

    Permitted for socioeconomic grounds & all above reasons: Barbados (MMR 27), Belize (MMR 28), St. Vincent and the Grenadines (MMR 45)

     

    Abortion without restriction: Puerto Rico (MMR 14), Uruguay (MMR 15), Guyana (MMR 229)[9]

     

6.     Improving access to, and the quality of, pre-natal and postnatal healthcare in developing countries (not liberalizing abortion laws) will decrease the number of maternal deaths worldwide. In the past 30 years, maternal mortality has decreased by over one-third across the world.[10] Few abortion laws have been liberalized during that time, and some have even become more restrictive. So what was the major change? A Lancet study found that progress has been made in preventing pregnant women from dying based on the following four main reasons: (1) declining pregnancy rates in some countries; (2) higher per capita income; (3) higher education rates for women; and (4) increasing availability of basic medical care, including “skilled birth attendants.” Legalizing abortion was not listed as one of the reasons.[11]

 

  1.  List of Countries with the Lowest and Highest Maternal Mortality Rates in 2015  

 

  1. Countries with Lowest Maternal Mortality Rates in 2015 (maternal deaths reported per 100,000 live births)Finland (3), Greece (3), Iceland (3), Poland (3), Austria (4), Belarus (4), Czech Republic (4), Italy (4), Kuwait (4), Sweden (4), Israel (5), Japan (5), Norway (5), Spain (5), Switzerland (5), Australia (6), Denmark (6), Germany (6), Slovak Republic (6), United Arab Emirates (6), Belgium (7), Canada (7), Cyprus (7), Montenegro (7), Netherlands (7), Croatia (8), France (8), Ireland (8), Macedonia, FYR (8), Estonia (9), Libya (9), Malta (9), Slovenia (9), United Kingdom (9), Lithuania (10), Luxembourg (10), Portugal (10), Singapore (10), Bosnia and Herzegovina (11), Bulgaria (11), Korea, Republic (11), New Zealand (11), Kazakhstan (12), Saudi Arabia (12), Qatar (13), Puerto Rico (14), United States (14), Bahrain (15), Lebanon (15), Uruguay (15), Turkey (16), Hungary (17), Oman (17), Serbia (17), Latvia (18), Thailand (20), Chile (22), Brunei Darussalam (23), Moldova (23), Ukraine (24), Armenia (25), Azerbaijan (25), Costa Rica (25), Iran, Islamic Republic (25), Russian Federation (25) Countries with Highest Maternal Mortality Rates in 2015 (maternal deaths reported per 100,000 live births)Burkina Faso (371), Afghanistan (396), Benin (405), Congo, Republic (442), Zimbabwe (443), Angola (477), Lesotho (487), Mozambique (489), Eritrea (501), Kenya (510), Guinea-Bissau (549), Niger (553), Mali (587), Camaroon (596), Mauritania (602), Malawi (634), Cote d’lvoire (645), Guinea (679), Congo, Democratic Republic (693), the Gambia (706), Burundi (712), Liberia (725), Somalia (732), South Sudan (789), Nigeria (814), Chad (856), Central African Republic (882), Sierra Leone (1360)

 

 

  1. [1] Major, B., Cozzarelli, C., Cooper, M. L., Zubek, J., Richards, C., Wilhite, M., Gramzow, R. H. (2000). Psychological Responses of Women After First-Trimester Abortions. Archives of General Psychology, 57, 777- 784.[2] United Families International. (2007). Guide to Family Issues: Abortion. ‌https://unitedfamilies.org/wp-content/uploads/‌2015/09/Abortion_GuidetoFamilyIssues.pdf[3] A meta-analysis published in The Lancet found that hemorrhage accounted for 27.1 percent of maternal deaths, hypertensive disorders 14 percent, and sepsis 10.7 percent. Say, L., et al. (2014). Global causes of maternal death: a WHO systematic analysis. Lancet Global Health, 2(6). doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/S2214-109X(14)70227-X[4] Lawson, G. W., Keirse, M., (2013). Reflections on the Maternal Mortality Millennium Goal. Birth, 40(2), 96-102.[5] WHO, UNICEF, UNFPA, World Bank Group and the United Nations Population Division. (2015). Trends in Maternal Mortality: 1990 to 2015.[6] Koch, E. (2015). The epidemiology of abortion and its prevention in Chili. Issues in Law & Medicine, 30, 71-85.[7] Koch, E., Chireau, M., Pliego, F., et al. (2015). Abortion legislation, maternal healthcare, fertility, female literacy, sanitation, violence against women and maternal deaths: a natural experiment in 32 Mexican states. British Medical Journal Open  5 :e006013 doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2014006013[8] Rolnick, J. A., & Vorhies, J. S. (2012). Legal restrictions and complications of abortion: Insights from data on complication rates in the United States. Journal of Public Health Policy 33, 348-362. doi:10.1057/jphp.2012.12[9] WHO, UNICEF, UNFPA, World Bank Group and the United Nations Population Division. (2015). Trends in Maternal Mortality: 1990 to 2015.[10] Hogan, M. C., et al. (2010). Maternal mortality for 181 countries, 1980—2008: a systematic analysis of progress towards Millennium Development Goal 5. The Lancet, 375, 1609-1613 (estimating a decrease from 526,300 maternal deaths in 1980 to 342,900 maternal deaths in 2008).

    [11] Ibid.

 

 

UN Consensus Language in Context

 

  • By 2030, reduce the global maternal mortality ratio to less than 70 per 100,000 live births. – 2030 Agenda (2015), 3.1.

 

  • To promote physical and mental health and well-being, and to extend life expectancy for all, we must achieve universal health coverage and access to quality health care. No one must be left behind. We commit to accelerating the progress made to date in reducing newborn, child and maternal mortality by ending all such preventable deaths before 2030. We are committed to ensuring universal access to sexual and reproductive health-care services, including for family planning, information and education. We will equally accelerate the pace of progress made in fighting malaria, HIV/AIDS, tuberculosis, hepatitis, Ebola and other communicable diseases and epidemics, including by addressing growing anti-microbial resistance and the problem of unattended diseases affecting developing countries. We are committed to the prevention and treatment of non-communicable diseases, including behavioural, developmental and neurological disorders, which constitute a major challenge for sustainable development. – 2030 Agenda (2015), 26.

 

  • All countries, with the support of all sections of the international community, must expand the provision of maternal health services in the context of primary health care. These services, based on the concept of informed choice, should include education on safe motherhood, pre-natal care that is focused and effective, maternal nutrition programmes, adequate delivery assistance that avoids excessive recourse to caesarean sections and provides for obstetric emergencies; referral services for pregnancy, childbirth and abortion complications; post-natal care and family planning. All births should be assisted by trained persons, preferably nurses and midwives, but at least by trained birth attendants. The underlying causes of maternal morbidity and mortality should be identified, and attention should be given to the development of strategies to overcome them and for adequate evaluation and monitoring mechanisms to assess the progress being made in reducing maternal mortality and morbidity and to enhance the effectiveness of ongoing programmes. Programmes and education to engage men’s support for maternal health and safe motherhood should be developed. – ICPD (1994), 8.22.

 

•  HRC Protection of the Family Resolution  •

 

Conscious that the majority of the internationally agreed development goals, especially those relating to the reduction of poverty, education of children and the reduction of maternal mortality, would be difficult to attain unless the strategies to achieve them focus on the family, which can contribute positively to, inter alia, eradicating poverty and hunger, achieving universal primary education, promoting gender equality and empowering women, reducing child mortality, improving maternal health, and combating HIV/AIDS, malaria and other diseases, — Protection of the Family Resolution, HRC, (2015), Preamble.

 

 

Return to Table of Contents