Overview
When language is proposed calling for the elimination of “barriers” without defining what those “barriers” are, it is often intended to be interpreted as a mandate to remove any laws or restrictions on services such as abortion, contraception or explicit sexuality education for minors, or parental consent requirements for such. The lack of government funding for contraception, “sex-change” operations, abortion, or other controversial services has also been characterized as a “barrier.” See specific examples below.
Whenever language is proposed calling for the elimination of “barriers,” the question must be asked, what kind of barriers does this mean? Are laws barriers? If so, which ones? Is parental consent the “barrier” or lack of government funding? Probing questions can help bring out the true intentions behind such proposals. Indeed, insisting that a list of the specific “barriers” such language is supposed to address be included in the text can also flush out deceptive intentions.
Examples of How “Barriers” Has Been Defined
- According to the Guttmacher Institute, “barriers” to abortion and post abortion care for adolescents include “legal restrictions, such as requiring parental notification or consent,”[1]
- According to the Bali Global Youth Forum Declaration, the outcome document from the UNFPA- and Planned Parenthood-sponsored youth review of ICPD:
“Cultural and religious barriers such as parental and spousal consent should never prevent access to safe and legal abortion, and other reproductive health services – recognizing that young people have autonomy over their own bodies, pleasures, and desires. (p. 10)
- As per their report, “ICPD and Human Rights: 20 years of advancing reproductive rights,” UNFPA lists “restrictive abortion laws” and “illegal abortion” as “barriers” to “reproductive rights.” It also identifies laws criminalizing same-sex behavior or HIV transmission as “barriers” to the fulfillment of reproductive rights. This same UNFPA report calls for the removal of:
- “barriers to realizing sexual and reproductive health and rights” [Translation: laws restricting abortion or regulating sexual behavior]
- “barriers to sexuality education, such as parental consent”
- “barriers to accessing safe abortion services, such as third-party authorization requirements [Translation: parental consent for abortion]”
- “barriers to accessing contraception, including … emergency contraception”
- barriers [for adolescents] in accessing comprehensive sexual and reproductive health services—“laws denying adolescents decision making capacity or requiring that they obtain parental consent”
- According to the World Health Organization:
- “Laws that prohibit or criminalize the use of certain medical procedures represent, by definition, a barrier to access. Such laws and other legal restrictions may prevent access to certain commodities needed for sexual and reproductive health (e.g. contraceptives), they may directly outlaw a particular service (e.g. abortion), or they may ban the provision of sexual and reproductive information through school-based or other education programmes.” (pg. 16, 2.4.—Criminalization of sexual-health-related services)
- “Barriers to sexual health that are susceptible to regulation by law include: access to essential medicines, conscientious objection by health-care providers…” (pg. 14, 2—Creating enabling legal and regulatory frameworks and eliminating barriers)
Talking Points
1. What kind of barriers does this mean? Are laws barriers? If so, which ones? This is too vague and unclear.
2. As per their report, “ICPD and Human Rights: 20 years of advancing reproductive rights,” UNFPA lists “restrictive abortion laws” and “illegal abortion” as “barriers” to “reproductive rights.” UNFPA’s report identifies laws criminalizing same-sex behavior or HIV transmission as “barriers” to the fulfillment of reproductive rights.
3. UNFPA’s report also calls for the removal of:
- “barriers to realizing sexual and reproductive health and rights”
- “barriers to sexuality education, such as parental consent”
- “barriers to accessing safe abortion services, such as third-party authorization requirements [parental consent for abortion]”
- “barriers to accessing contraception, including . . . emergency contraception”
- barriers [for adolescents] in accessing comprehensive sexual and reproductive health services—“laws denying adolescents decision making capacity or requiring that they obtain parental consent”
[1] Adolescents’ Need for and Use of Abortion Services in Developing Countries. (2016). Guttmacher Institute. Retrieved from https://www.guttmacher.org/fact-sheet/adolescents-need-and-use-abortion-services-developing-countries
[2] UNFPA and Center for Reproductive Rights. The Right to Contraceptive Information and Services for Women and Adolescents. (2010). Retrieved from https://www.unfpa.org/sites/default/files/resource-pdf/Contraception.pdf