(See also “Human Rights Defenders“)
Overview
One of the most effective negotiation strategies used to advance controversial sexual rights that undermine the family is to claim these alleged rights are basic or fundamental human rights, or better yet, internationally recognized human rights protected by international human rights instruments. Attempts to advance sexual rights as human rights have increased in recent years as rogue UN agencies, committees, Special Rapporteurs and treaty monitoring bodies work together in an attempt to create new and controversial sexual rights to which UN Member States have not consensually agreed. (For more detail on the aggressive promotion of abortion by UN entities see the FWI Policy Brief titled “The Relentless Push to Create an ‘International Right’ to Abortion.”)
Just one example of many where UN agencies are distorting human rights to advance a sexual “rights” agenda is a 2015 report by the World Health Organization titled Sexual Health, Human Rights and the Law. The report calls for every country to remove restrictions on abortions, provide sex-change surgery, and remove criminal restrictions on sexual conduct such as extramarital sex, prostitution, and homosexual behavior as a matter of human rights.[1]
Consider the following three abuses of the UN system which, if allowed to stand, can continue to undermine the sovereignty and religious and cultural values of Member States:
- Unlike the fixed characteristics of race or sex, “sexual orientation” and “gender identity” are not protected classes in either the UN Charter or in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) and were not terms commonly used at the time the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) was negotiated in 1976. Moreover, “sexual orientation” provisions have been specifically rejected many times by the majority of UN Member States since 1976. Yet the ICESR committee has unabashedly argued that the words “other status” in the ICESCR include “sexual orientation” and “gender identity” as an attempt to make them protected classes and thus international human rights.
- In 2006, nine UN Special Rapporteurs and 21 sexual rights activists calling themselves “The International Commission of Jurists and the International Service for Human Rights” and defining themselves as “experts,” developed a document titled the Yogyakarta Principles, which, in essence, is a wish list of sexual rights relating to orientation and gender identity that UN Member States would not be able to restrict or limit. The drafters claimed these Principles “reflect the existing state of international human rights law in relation to issues of sexual orientation and gender identity” and “affirm binding international legal standards with which all States must comply.” Yet the drafters failed to identify the supposed “binding legal standards” on which the Principles are based. At that time, “sexual orientation” and “gender identity” were not mentioned in any UN treaty or other consensus document. Yet UN agencies have attempted multiple times to promote these concepts in UN documents, citing the Yogyakarta Principles as the authority. (For more detail on the Yogyakarta Principles see the FWI Policy Brief titled “The Yogyakarta Principles.”)
- The CEDAW Committee alone has pressured more than 65 countries to change their laws and legalize abortion, even though UN consensus language clearly states: “Any measures or changes related to abortion within the health system can only be determined at the national or local level according to the national legislative process.” (ICPD, Par. 8.25; Beijing, Par. 106-k; ICPD+5, Par. 63.) UN consensus language also makes it clear that “In no case should abortion be promoted as a method of family planning,” but that has not stopped UN bureaucrats from undermining national sovereignty by claiming a broad right exists to abortion on demand.
Below you will find additional examples of how various United Nations entities are distorting the concept of “human rights” to promote controversial sexual and abortion rights.
The following quote from a United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) publication reveals that UNFPA uses the terms “human rights” and “rights to non-discrimination” as euphemisms for “sexual rights” because they know many nations will oppose “sexual rights”:
- “In El Salvador, where conservative opposition to sexual rights is fierce, the strategy had been to focus on human rights, especially the right to non-discrimination, as even the most adamant opposition finds it difficult to defend discrimination.”[2]
The following are direct quotes from the 2015 World Health Organization (WHO) publication Sexual Health, Human Rights and the Law, showing more distortions of human rights:
- “In order to respect and protect human rights, states must ensure that health systems and services are able to meet the specific sexual and reproductive health needs of adolescents, including contraception and safe abortion services.” (3.4.1) In other words, WHO defines “human rights” to include abortion.
- This WHO quote claims that requiring parental consent for sexual and reproductive health services is a violation of the rights of adolescents: “Human rights standards at the international, regional and national levels are well developed regarding the protection of adolescents under 18 from discrimination in accessing both information and services for sexual health to guarantee adolescents’ rights to privacy and confidentiality by providing sexual and reproductive health services without parental consent on the basis of their evolving capacities.” (3.4.1, “Adolescents (under 18 years of age)”).
- “International human rights standards explicitly call for the decriminalization of consensual same-sex sexual activity, and have established that such criminal laws are in breach of human rights.” (3.4.7, “Sexual orientation and gender identity”).
- “Human rights bodies… urge states to recognize the right of transgender persons to change their legal gender by permitting the issuance of new birth certificates.” (3.4.8, “Transgender and gender variant people”).
- “In order to respect and protect human rights, states must ensure that health systems and services are able to meet the specific sexual and reproductive health needs of adolescents, including contraception and safe abortion services.” (3.4.1, “Adolescents (under 18 years of age)”).
- “Human rights standards at the international, regional and national levels are well developed regarding the protection of adolescents under 18 from discrimination in accessing both information and services for sexual health to guarantee adolescents’ rights to privacy and confidentiality by providing sexual and reproductive health services without parental consent on the basis of their evolving capacities.” (3.4.1, “Adolescents (under 18 years of age)”).
Talking Points
When a new controversial right is proposed that is not clearly based in a binding UN document and that has never been agreed upon by all UN Member States, the following points can be made to call for its deletion:
1. Only the General Assembly has the authority to develop new international human rights by consensus among Member States. According to the UN Charter, “The General Assembly shall initiate studies and make recommendations for the purpose of … assisting in the realization of human rights and fundamental freedoms for all without distinction as to race, sex, language, or religion.” – U.N. Charter (1945), Article 13
2. The UN Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC) can make recommendations with regard to human rights and fundamental freedoms, but such recommendations must be made to the General Assembly under which the ECOSOC derives its authority. – U.N. Charter (1945), Articles 55, 62, 66
Thus, based on the UN Charter:
- UN committees, UN Special Rapporteurs, other UN bodies and outside experts have no authority to create new international human rights that have not been developed by Member States and recorded in binding treaties or at least in UN consensus documents.
- When a report or recommendation from a UN agency, rapporteur, committee, or experts working for a UN body claims that international law requires Member States to honor commitments involving new alleged human rights, they are operating outside of their mandate. In such cases, they should be promptly and publicly reprimanded by UN Member States.
- The process to establish new international human rights should be deliberate and transparent, invoking careful and thorough debate at the General Assembly level.
UN consensus documents always should safeguard the right of national sovereignty in a way that makes all commitments under negotiation subject to that right, as well as to national religious, ethical and cultural values.
[1] World Health Organization. (2015). Sexual Health, Human Rights and the Law. Retrieved from https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/175556/1/9789241564984_eng.pdf?ua=1
[2] United Nations Population Fund, “Comprehensive Sexuality Education: Advancing Human Rights, Gender Equality and Improved Sexual and Reproductive Health,” p. 49.